Genres in Arguments

In our book, “Writing Arguments”, there are two different examples of the same view on genetically engineered foods. The two of express the same feelings about this topic. They both believe that “GE” foods are bad. Even though they are alike there are two differences between them. They are genre and topic.

The first example is a political cartoon. A “hippie” is shown with an ear of genetically altered corn. He is waving it in the face of a starved tribal boy. He states that the boy does not want the corn, because it has been genetically engineered. This represents a visual argument. There is only one side to it and the topic is directed to GE food all together. The other example is the advertisement of a tomato can. There is writing on the can about labeling foods correctly and then below is a paragraph on properly labeling GE foods. This is a public affairs advocacy advertisement. The topic is narrowed down from genetically engineered foods to how they should have labels on them to warn customers.

Genre is a major part of arguments. The style in which you present your opinions can decide whether people will take your side or not. Factual support is must in these scenarios. Usually cartoons will not be taken seriously.